58% of Leaders Rate Themselves Exceptional: The Comms Belief Gap

About this episode

More than half of leaders say they’re exceptional at communicating clearly. Barely a quarter strongly agree that leadership communication actually works. New Gallup data puts a number on something Jenni sees in leadership teams all the time: leaders judge communication by what they sent, and employees judge it by what they understood and believed.

That gap runs through the whole episode. Chuck and Jenni weigh up two new job titles pitched at comms teams, the chief conversation officer and the narrative architect. They look at Harvard Business Review research on what happens to team trust when people ask AI before they ask a colleague, and at Gartner’s guide to deciding what to cut, protect and invest in at budget time. They also disagree, a little, over Canva’s layoffs and whether a generous exit package deserves applause. It starts with Jensen Huang’s resignation from Nvidia and what happens when a CEO becomes the brand.

Listen now on:

Key takeaways from this episode

Show notes

When the CEO becomes the brand

Chuck is back from a week in Madrid, his first trip to a country where English isn’t the main language, and he talks about how freeing it felt to make mistakes and find people patient and welcoming. Then to the news of the week: Nvidia announced that Jensen Huang has resigned as CEO, naming CFO Colette Kress interim CEO and Harvey Jones its first-ever board chair.

Neither host claims to be an Nvidia expert, but both are interested in the hero status we give leaders like Huang, Elon Musk and Steve Jobs. Jenni says the danger comes when the CEO becomes the brand, because rebuilding trust and credibility afterward is a huge job. She hopes it pushes other organizations to put the wider leadership team forward. Chuck questions the board’s role in letting a company that size go without a clear succession plan, but doesn’t think Nvidia’s future rests on one person. The company, he says, is bigger than its CEO.

Chief conversation officer or narrative architect?

Two new roles are being pitched at comms. Vanessa Van Edwards, whom Chuck and Jenni saw speak in Nashville, talked on Instagram about the “chief conversation officer”, someone who keeps an organization’s conversational strength up. And Gab Ferree shared Michael Margolis’s idea of the “narrative architect”, built on the argument that every company is now a language system, AI runs on that language, and whoever writes the source documents shapes everything people and agents produce.

Chuck has seen this before, in the era of social media ninjas and wizards. He’d caution anyone against leaning on a title, especially when comms rarely has a full picture of the narratives employees are actually experiencing. Calling yourself the architect of those narratives without that understanding is a risky place to stand. Jenni doesn’t think either title will take off, but she does think the need behind the chief conversation officer is real. Pointing to the Edelman Trust Barometer’s findings on trust between peers, she argues that organizations have lost the skill of difficult conversations and productive disagreement.

Relationslipping: when AI replaces the colleague

Harvard Business Review looks at what happens to team dynamics when employees turn to AI instead of each other. It builds on the late social psychologist Dan Wegner’s idea of a transactive memory system, a team’s shared map of who knows what. Think of a couple where one person handles the finances and the other remembers birthdays, or a Formula One pit crew where nobody rechecks anyone else’s job. That map gets updated through everyday conversations, and when people ask AI instead, it stops being updated.

The authors surveyed just over 1,000 US desk workers on project teams. The more people went to AI instead of a teammate, the more trust and coordination fell, a pattern the authors call “relationslipping.” About one in five admit they go to AI first. The reasons include trusting AI, low psychological safety and the simple fact that AI is agreeable and colleagues can be hard work. It shows up across age, seniority, industry and team size.

Chuck can see how it happens. He says the biggest strength an internal communicator has is being a connector across the business, and the people in those other departments will always know more than AI. He only asks AI to do things he can’t do or doesn’t enjoy doing, and calls it the worst creative partner he has ever worked with. Jenni thinks the damage happens in the quick everyday questions you’d once have asked a colleague, which are what build a relationship in the first place. She also reminds communicators that much of their work is creative, and efficiency isn’t the goal of a creative process.

Cut, protect, invest: Gartner’s guide to comms budgets

With budget season underway, Jenni brings Gartner’s research on finding the right communications investment mix in the AI era, based on a survey of 200 communications leaders in North America and Europe. The framework sorts every activity and spend line into three groups. Cut what no longer adds strategic value, including “zombie projects” kept alive by tradition or a senior sponsor. Protect the trust-building work tied to business outcomes. Invest in the tools and skills that make a measurable difference.

Jenni’s four steps from the report: start from a blank page, link everything you protect to a business outcome and keep the measurement that proves it, fund new skills and tools by stopping things, and plan for more than one budget scenario with quarterly check-ins. Asked for a regular zombie project, Chuck nominates SharePoint, which nobody seems to want but nobody will put out of its misery. Jenni would cut the vanity projects head office cares about and protect the parties, barbecues and other culture work that brings people together. Chuck adds one step to the front of the list: start with the goals, then check what you spend against them.

Canva’s layoffs: a better way, or just less bad?

Canva’s restructure affects 22% of its workforce, and the support package for people leaving has drawn plenty of praise. It includes at least six months’ salary regardless of location, removal of the one-year vesting cliff, 12 months of healthcare where Canva already provides it, career coaching, the chance to keep their MacBook and US$10,000 grants for anyone starting something of their own. Others, including this LinkedIn post, argue the story shouldn’t be framed as good news at all.

Jenni asks whether it’s realistic to say layoffs should never happen, and if they do, whether this is the way to do them with care. Chuck is in the “why are we celebrating this?” camp. He points to AI spending and growth falling short of expectations, and asks why a company that is still growing is letting this many people go. The package is generous compared with what other companies offer, he says, but not as generous as keeping your job. Jenni agrees layoffs should be a last resort, pointing back to the Gund Company’s record of never laying anyone off. But if a company does end up there, she thinks this should become the standard. They settle on “a better way” rather than “the right way.”

Gallup: leaders measure what they sent

The last story, which came to Jenni via Katie Macaulay of The Internal Comms Podcast, is Gallup’s article on how organizations can improve leadership communication. Only 27% of leaders strongly agree that leadership communicates effectively, and the figure is lower still for managers and individual contributors. Yet 58% of leaders rate themselves exceptional or outstanding at communicating clearly, compared with 33% of managers who rate their own leader that way.

Gallup often points to training managers as the fix, but Jenni reads this data as saying the issue starts at the top, with leaders who aren’t aligned passing on messages that are already unclear. She asks whether the self-assessment gap opens the door to a conversation with leaders or just makes them defensive. Chuck says it’s both, and compares it to the way most people think they’re a better driver than average. His advice is to frame it as how everyone can get better, not who’s good and who isn’t. Jenni describes a client who asked her how to show the impact of their CEO’s communication, and says measuring impact helps move the conversation away from individual behavior.

Freq-outs

Jenni is freq-ing out about a LinkedIn graphic that repeats “comms is not a support function, comms is strategy” line after line, and has drawn thousands of likes. In the organizations she worked in, support functions included HR, finance, strategy, comms and marketing, all supporting the parts of the business that bring in revenue. So why the allergic reaction? Chuck is wary of any post where the crowd piles on, and argues it isn’t either/or. Finance supports the business and is strategic too. He’d ask people to think critically before they repost.

Chuck’s freq-out is a happier one. His trip to Madrid lined up with a Duran Duran show, which turned out to be drummer Roger Taylor’s last. At his first ever solo concert, a tap on the shoulder turned out to be a friend from Butler University he hadn’t seen in 30 years. They all ended up out for drinks, and Chuck’s takeaway for listeners is simple: be good to people, because you never know who you’ll bump into 30 years later.

Listen now on:

Timestamps

  • 00:00 Welcome
  • 00:41 Chuck’s week in Madrid
  • 04:23 Jensen Huang resigns: when the CEO becomes the brand
  • 07:47 Chief conversation officer and narrative architect
  • 12:19 HBR: relationslipping and the cost of asking AI first
  • 21:04 Gartner: cut, protect, invest for comms budgets
  • 26:16 Canva’s layoffs and the package for people leaving
  • 32:43 Gallup: the leadership communication belief gap
  • 37:56 Jenni’s freq-out: why do we hate being a support function?
  • 42:33 Chuck’s freq-out: Duran Duran and a friend from college
  • 45:50 Wrap

Questions answered

What is relationslipping? It’s the term Harvard Business Review authors use for working relationships slowly weakening as people go to AI instead of their colleagues. In teams where that is normal, the authors report lower trust and coordination.

What is a transactive memory system? An idea from social psychologist Dan Wegner. It’s a group’s shared map of who knows what, so nobody has to hold everything. It’s built and updated through everyday conversations between colleagues.

What is Gartner’s cut, protect, invest framework for comms budgets? Every activity and spend line goes into one of three groups: cut what no longer adds strategic value, protect trust-building work tied to business outcomes, and invest in tools and skills that make a measurable difference.

What did Gallup find about leadership communication? Only 27% of leaders strongly agree that leadership communicates effectively, yet 58% rate themselves exceptional or outstanding at communicating clearly. Just 33% of managers rate their direct leader that highly.

How is Canva supporting the employees affected by its restructure? People leaving get at least six months’ salary regardless of location, 12 months of healthcare where Canva already provides it, career support, the option to keep their MacBook and access to US$10,000 grants to start something of their own.

Is internal communication a support function? Chuck and Jenni say it can be both. Support functions such as HR and finance support the parts of the business that bring in revenue, and that work can still be strategic.

Full podcast transcript

Chuck: Welcome to Frequency. I’m Chuck Gose.

Jenni: And I’m Jenni Field. Frequency is your go-to for real talk about comms, culture, and employee experience beyond the buzzwords and straight to what matters. And today we are talking about the new roles in comms teams that focus on conversation and narratives. I’m also bringing a report because I can, and this is one from Gartner about finding the right communications investment mix in the AI era. I also want to delve into some recent research around what happens to team dynamics when you ask AI instead of a colleague. We’re going to talk about how to improve leadership comms according to Gallup, and I want to dig into the Canva job losses story that has been doing the rounds with divided opinion.

Chuck: And before we get into all that, one, it’s great to be back and recording with you, Jenni, because we recorded a bit earlier the week before. Because I was traveling to Madrid and I was there for a week with my wife Kristen. We were truly able to unplug. I think I pulled my laptop out once and it was not for work purposes. It was to do some research on something else, because sometimes I’m just more comfortable working on a laptop to look at things than my phone.

Jenni: Yeah, I mean, you have boomered me a few times. I feel like this is a boomer moment for you.

Chuck: I know, I know. I feel like that’s just straight Gen X, though, for that one. But it was my first time visiting Madrid and obviously, therefore, also visiting Spain. And I just want to kind of talk a little bit about what that experience was like, because once I got there, I had a realization it was the first time I’d visited a country where English was not the dominant language, and obviously Spanish is there. And the vulnerability and injecting yourself into those environments, knowing you’re going to make mistakes, and them also knowing you are going to make mistakes. And just the general patience and welcoming that we felt when we were there. It was a really great experience to go to a new city. There was, you know, got to visit with Regine Nelson and her family who’d recently moved to Madrid and navigating public transportation. Timing worked out well, in addition to seeing a great Bengals victory at Bernabéu Stadium, but also getting to go to a Duran Duran show, which I’ll then talk about in my freq-out a little bit later. But just really jumping into a city. We stayed in a great part of the city just north of Retiro Park, which is just to Americanize it, their version of Central Park to be in. So having access to that, but being in a nice area with a lot of restaurants nearby. Again, going in the restaurants where there’s no English anywhere and making mistakes. My wife Kristen, who’s been taking Spanish classes, so she was able to practice. And it was fun to hear her tell people that she was learning and can I practice? And them wanting to do that. But also the reminder of the power of broken language and how, like, I know there’s some judgments that a lot of Americans have when people speak broken English or things aren’t perfect. Well, nobody speaks perfect English. I’m sorry to share with people who think that they do. So why would someone who, if this is English, is their second, third, or fourth language, like why would that be perfect? But how you can pretty simply get some points across that things aren’t in a proper tense, or my gosh, you used the wrong language, you know, the wrong word here or there. But also as a good chance for me to learn and ask Kristen questions, like, wait a minute. So what would I say in this situation? Or one morning I went out to pick up breakfast on my own. So going into an empanadas restaurant and attempting to remember the language and recite what I’d practiced, but then have them ask me questions that I was not prepared to answer. But we figured it out. And that’s kind of the beauty of being a tourist and welcoming that tourist mentality into it. And yeah, it was a it was a really great trip, a beautiful city. I would love to go back at some other time because there’s so much more to explore. We did not leave Madrid. Obviously there’s many more things to see in Spain. But again, encouraging ourselves and patting ourselves on the back a bit for being tourists, but throwing yourself into some tricky situations, being vulnerable, making mistakes, but coming out of it all the better.

Jenni: Yeah. It’s a new experience, isn’t it? I think it’s lovely. Lovely.

Chuck: Yeah. And then before we get into your stories though, one of the things we did want to talk about as we’re recording today, we are learning about Jensen Huang’s resignation as CEO of Nvidia. If we didn’t talk about it, it’d be like a whole other week. Who knows what’s going to come out as a result of this? Before we started recording, we both acknowledge neither of us are experts on Nvidia or Jensen’s history or any of that. I just wanted to bring it into the conversation to talk more about this hero-like or cult-like status that we assign to leaders, whether it’s Jensen, whether it’s Elon Musk, whether it was Steve Jobs in the past or Bill Gates before. Like we there’s an idolatry that we put on these individuals and it’s a reminder that they are far, far from perfect out there. They might have been really strong leaders in that company. They’re not perfect individuals. Nor am I condoning anything having to do with affairs or Chinese spies or government relationships or anything like that’s going on. But it’s just that I just wonder now what it’s like to be an employee at Nvidia, where for so long things were going almost so great for that company. What’s it like today to be an Nvidia employee?

Jenni: It’s the danger, I think, of where your CEO becomes the brand and I think that makes it really hard especially for some of these really big tech firms. You know, you mentioned Steve Jobs, mentioned Bill Gates. They are human beings and I think that it just gets really messy then because there’s just so much work to do to rebuild the brand and the leadership team and the trust and the credit. Like you’ve got so much to do, and I think we’ve talked about it before here about you shouldn’t go all in on the CEO, it should be the leadership team and I wonder if this is gonna make some other organisations reflect on that maybe and start to bring other people forward in the same way and spread that a little bit so it’s not all on one person.

Chuck: The other interesting thing I learned is that apparently they did not have a succession plan in place. In fact, this is a big thing from Jensen is that his plan was to run the company until he died, which we could do all sorts of therapy on that conversation. But the fact that there wasn’t a plan in place for this, which shows that sort of infallibility, like they did not think something could ever happen.

Jenni: Yeah. I love the belief that you’re in control of when that might happen for you. Like, do you know what I mean? That to me is just poor risk judgment, you know, in terms of being able to have the resilience of the organisation and those things. So wow. Wow.

Chuck: Yeah, and also what was the role of the board? Was the board being like, no, no, no, that’s cool, Jensen. Cool. Cool, cool, cool. But like, no, we really need to have a succession plan should something happen. So, yeah, a big fail there. But also, I saw some people questioning now like the future of Nvidia. I am not one of those. I think when you’ve got a company that’s been as successful as them, it’s not just about Jensen Huang. It’s not the reason they are successful. I think that’s a great reminder to all these CEOs out there that yes, they might achieve this pseudo-like rock star status, but the company is way bigger than them. And I think Nvidia is just gonna further prove that.

Jenni: Yeah, definitely. Right, let’s get into the articles. The first one today is about these future of comms roles. So Vanessa Van Edwards, who we saw in Nashville last year, she was on Instagram a few weeks ago talking about the new CCO, the chief conversation officer. Now she thinks we’re going to have more roles that are managing the conversations at work. She wants us to keep our conversational strength up and talks about conversation facilitators and officers. I have thoughts. Then you shared with me another new role coming for the comms function, and that’s a narrative architect. Now, this is the brainchild of Michael Margolis, who is ex-Meta. Leave that there. Now, according to Gab Ferree, who shared it on LinkedIn, she said that this is about language being the new currency of organisations with AI. She said in her LinkedIn post, he taught us that every company is now a language system, and AI runs on that language. Whoever writes the source documents shapes everything people and agents produce downstream and she did it with sort of the eyes emoji, sort of looking at comms teams. So we’ve got a chief conversation officer, we have got a narrative architect. So Chuck, I’m not even gonna really start with an opinion here. I’m just gonna pass you the mic.

Chuck: I just go back to let’s say maybe 15 years ago when we had a lot of social media ninjas. Do you remember that? There were a lot of ninjas, there were a lot of wizards. And so now we’re also architects. There’s prompt engineers. Like this obsession with figuring out this next thing. I remember one person even calling themselves a CEO, and I’m like, my gosh, I didn’t know you were a CEO. He’s like, No, I’m the chief explosion officer. So I think it’s one thing to think about the theoretical roles, like what should we be doing? What are the processes in place? I think the titles then take away from…

Jenni: I nearly swore then. Get in the bin.

Chuck: …that if you were to go into a conversation with your boss or your supervisor, your CEO, whoever, and be like, I’m gonna be, what was this, the narrative architect. What? What?

Jenni: What? What? I think the chief conversation officer is interesting, not because I think the title really is gonna take off, but because I think the need to help organisations converse is true. I think that if we look at the breakdown of trust at work, which we’ve talked about before, we look at the Edelman Trust Barometer that was out in sort of February time this year that talked about this issue with peers trusting each other and that shifting in terms of people not having the same values. I don’t think we know how to have difficult conversations. I don’t think we know how to have productive disagreement. I think we’ve lost a lot of those skills over the years in how to do that. So I can see a need to allow space for that. I don’t think it’s going to be a chief conversation officer, but I think the essence of that in terms of how do you help people actually, you know, become human beings and work well together, I think is something that is possibly something that is going to come up more in organisations. I do think there’s a need potentially for that.

Chuck: Yeah, I agree. That’s why I think it’s the essence of this, of like how do conversations impact the role that you’re in? What role, what impact can you have on the conversations that are happening? And even, let’s take it into something very tactical, like a town hall. We’ve all been a part of really awful town halls. The reason is because it’s rarely a conversation. The reason is because the narrative is off. The narrative that employees are experiencing is different than the narrative perhaps that leaders are sharing out there. I think where I would caution people is relying on these titles. Rely, again, on the essence of it, understanding. I don’t even know we have a good grasp of the narratives that employees are truly experiencing across an organization. So to think that we’re somehow an architect of those narratives without fully understanding what’s happening day to day in the business is a risky proposition to prop yourself up in that role.

Jenni: Yeah, it feels a little bit ego-driven for me, and I’ll leave that there. So the next article I want to talk about is from Harvard Business Review. This is about team dynamics and how they weaken when employees turn to AI instead of colleagues. Now, this idea comes from the late social psychologist Dan Wegner. He called it a transactive memory system. This is a group’s shared map of who knows what. And in the article, a couple of examples talking about in a relationship with your partner, one of you will stop trying to remember things that the other is good at because you know you can just ask, so one handles finances, the other remembers birthdays. Neither of you hold everything, but together you got it covered.

Chuck: Feels a bit like a personal attack on that one.

Jenni: If you feel seen, that’s you, that’s you. The other reference in the article is Formula One pit crew, so everyone knows their exact jobs, no one needs to recheck things, they just know that other people are going to do it and it’ll be done in like two seconds. So that map of who knows what is built through everyday conversations with colleagues. And if you stop asking colleagues and ask AI instead, the map stops getting updated, is what we’re saying. So the authors surveyed just over a thousand US full-time desk workers who work on project teams across about 20 industries. The good news is that the more people used AI, the more they felt their teammates had specialist distinctive knowledge, which I think is good news. The cost, however, is the more people went to AI instead of a teammate, the more trust and coordination fell. So this is what authors are calling displacement. And we have a new term, which we love on the podcast, which is relationslipping. And this means that working relationships slowly weaken as people swap colleagues for AI. In teams where displacement is normal, coordination is 22% lower and trust is 22% lower. Now, about one in five desk workers admit they tend to go to AI before a teammate. The authors give us three reasons about that. The first is beliefs about AI: people who are optimistic about AI are more likely to displace a colleague, and people who trust AI highly are twice as likely. Then the team climate, so people with low psychological safety, so they don’t feel safe asking questions or admitting they don’t know to a colleague, they will go to AI. And then the other one is that AI is agreeable, you know. It always says to me, That’s a great idea, Jenni. It doesn’t push back, whereas real colleagues might feel a bit like hard work. So those were the three reasons that people are doing it. It’s not about age or seniority, shows up equally across age, seniority, industry, and team size. And the authors say the cause is how organizations reward individual productivity, not the people. So they recommend making sure that people are talking every day, building psychological safety, being open about AI use and rewarding teamwork, and using AI to prepare for conversations, not to skip them. They do end with hope, which I love. So they talk about the fact that when the internet use first made households lonelier in the 1990s, a follow-up study three years later found that effect had faded. So people learned to use the internet to strengthen relationships instead of replacing them. So my question for you, relationslipping. Do you see it happening?

Chuck: I don’t know that I can make a judgment call and do I see it happening. I think I can see how that can happen. It is those one-on-one or one-on-few, whether it’s in-person or digital interactions that you have with employees or your coworkers, where you’re looking for information. And I think it ultimately for me, it comes down to why are you using AI? Not questioning the why, but what purpose? So we had a session inside ICology recently where we were talking about how is AI impacting individuals and teams across communications. And I lined it up was are you AI inclusive, AI dominant, or AI first? And everybody sort of weighed in on their own journeys in there. Ultimately, what it came down to is it depended on the size of your team, that if you’re a very small team, perhaps even a team of one, you are probably AI first and AI dominant because you don’t have a lot of people to go to around your specific thing that you’re doing. I think the danger is when people do have those resources or those assets available and still go to AI. Because I think speaking in the world of internal comms, your greatest strength is being that connector. I think I was even asked that question when we were at Unite around what’s the number one skill that I’d love to see communicators up. And it was around connecting. And I think the connections you have in other departments, other parts of the business strengthen your role. That’s the risk. If you relationslip those connections, yes, that is going to be at your detriment. If you’re relying on AI instead of those people, those people will always have more knowledge than AI ever will. So yeah, do I think relationslipping could be a thing? I could see how it could happen. Do I like the word? No, we’ll add it to our list of buzzwords. But I think it’s that model. I loved your example of the Formula One pit crew as a relatively recent Formula One fan. It’s amazing how those teams operate because people have they have that one job during the pit, but that’s not their only job. Those people are doing plenty of other things leading up to the race. After the race, when there’s not race season, but during that pit, you have that one job. There’s a lot that teams can learn about that when it is time for an event, a town hall, something going on. If every person on that team knows exactly what, and they’re not their job is not to necessarily help somebody else do their job, their job is to do their job.

Jenni: Yeah. I definitely think I can see it happening because I think there’s those quick everyday things that you’ll now go to AI for that you won’t ask Janice for, and it breaks down those little things that would build the relationship. So not necessarily about trusting each other or relying on each other, but if you haven’t got any foundation for the relationship, building that trust and reliability with a colleague is harder because you haven’t done the everyday stuff. Do you know what I mean? And I think I can see I can see how that would shift. So it’d be interesting to see what happens. At the same time as I was reading this article, something popped up from one of the tech vendors about “just ask AI,” you know, on their platform. And I sent them the link to this and I was like, the irony that I’ve seen your post today and at the same time there’s this. And they were like, We would never advocate for non-human stuff, which I love them for, but it’s interesting that there’s such there’s such a push towards using the tech, doing all of that, but maybe not considering the impact that’s going to have on the workplace and this trust issue and all that stuff. So I think it’s a watch this space thing for me.

Chuck: Well, and going back to the conversation we had inside ICology, when I reflected back on my own, I brought up the point that I only ask AI to do things that either I cannot do or I do not enjoy doing. Those are the only things I ask for it to do. And I got a little pushback from some members, like, yeah, but what if it’s better at or more efficient than the work that you’re doing? And I was like, I don’t care. If I’m enjoying that work, that is why I am working. I am not working to then ultimately produce the thing. That’s the enjoyment part of work. So I will only ask it to do things that either I, like, I do not know HTML code. I don’t know how to code anything. So I will ask AI to do that. Also, some data analysis, which I just do not enjoy, or merging data together, which I’m worried I might not get right. That’s what I’m gonna ask it to do.

Jenni: Yeah. I think it was Seinfeld who talked about the fact that efficiency is not the goal when it’s a creative process. Like you don’t want to be efficient because you want to iterate, you want to work through it, and you’re creating. And I think sometimes communicators forget to some degree you are creating things. You might be creating a story or a campaign or something, and efficiency is not the goal there, because you’ve got to go through that creative process to get there. If you don’t do that, then you haven’t you haven’t been creative. Do you know what I mean? You’re just being efficient. And I think that is an important distinction to think about as well.

Chuck: Also, AI is the worst creative partner I have ever worked with, period. End of sentence.

Jenni: Okay. Done. Let’s go on to the piece from Gartner, which is about finding the right communications investment mix in the AI era. Now this talks about the fact that heads of comms are under pressure to fund AI transformation and deliver measurable business impact with limited resources. But what should people stop, automate or double down on? Now, according to Gartner, the spend allocation model provides cut-protect-invest guidance on key communication budget areas. Full disclosure, this came out in July this year, but I came across it and wanted to talk about it today, because we’re in that sort of budget planning season for a lot of comms, HR, culture folks at the moment. And I thought this was helpful context if you’re trying to figure out what you want to do with your budget, time, everything for next year. So for this piece of research, they surveyed 200 communication leaders in North America and Europe between October and December 2025. This is what they’re saying. So their framework is cut, protect, invest. Go through every activity and every spend line and group it into these three areas. You cut the things that no longer add strategic value. They talk about zombie projects. We talked about zombie ideas in the past. Getting rid of long-standing traditions or maybe just work that somebody senior really cares about that you don’t actually need to do. Protect the essential, the trust-building work, the things that are tied to business outcomes, and invest in tools and skills that make a measurable difference. Probably AI, but analytics, automation, those things. So based on the report, these are the four things that I would be doing as a team. So starting with that blank page, don’t think about cutting the budget, just list everything you’re doing and spend money on and sort each item into those three things. You’ve got to prove why what you keep matters. So linking everything that you want to protect to a business outcome, such as trust, risk, change, leadership, visibility, confidence, resilience, whatever it is, but your measurement has to show that link, so protect that. The third is to pay for the future by stopping things. So we all know that budgets are unlikely to get bigger. So funding AI, automation, new skills, that’s the stuff to start to invest in. And the fourth is planning for more than one budget and checking in more often. So rather than, and this was in the report, so rather than focusing on the annual budget cycle, reviewing that maybe every quarter so that you can adjust and change as you go, I think that probably makes sense given the pace of organizations now. And I think maybe that annual budget cycle may be not quite right. So my question for you, Chuck, is about the zombie piece. So the report talks about zombie projects. We’ve talked about zombie ideas, which we talked about from Rob Briner in the past. And I just wondered if you had any zombie projects that sprung to mind for you that might be a regular zombie project for a comms team.

Chuck: One, I’m here for anything related to the zombie apocalypse. I love the analogy. We have this conversation in our house or we’ve had it where I am a survivor when the apocalypse happens. I’m in it for the fight. My wife Kristen has opted out. She wants no part of a post-apocalyptic world. Everybody can make their choices. When I thought about this, to me, anything related to SharePoint feels like this zombie project. Because it just keeps going. Nobody wants it around, nobody likes it. I’m not even convinced many Microsoft employees actually see the value in SharePoint. But yet it just keeps hanging around. Nobody will do the kill shot. Nobody’ll just put it out, put an end to the misery of it.

Jenni: So that’s yours. Okay, I like that. I was thinking about the stuff that is the sort of vanity project stuff that I think you get, like the stuff that people really care about that are stakeholders in head office, but my audience was always kind of frontline deskless workers for a lot of my career or manufacturing lines and things. It’s very similar to you. And I always thought there was so much stuff that you’d be talking about that you’d think no one cares about this. And I don’t know why we’re talking about it. But those things that don’t link back or don’t correlate, I’d be getting rid of those. I probably would be investing a bit more or protecting some of the stuff that is fun. So the Christmas party stuff, the summer sports things or barbecues, whatever it is, the stuff that is about the culture, about bringing people together, about relationship building. I would really want to protect those, and I think they are easy to cut, but I think the damage of that longer term we’re starting to see now. So those would be on my list.

Chuck: Yeah. To go back to yours, I love the idea of starting from a blank page. And that can be scary to a lot of teams, but to think about it from the standpoint of don’t start with everything you do and spend money on. Start with the goals. Then look at what are you doing and spending money on and how do those tie to the goals? If they don’t tie to the goals, okay, that’s an easy way to then cut if it’s not helping you achieve that. Or if you have a goal and like, man, we’re not investing in anything. Help us. Okay, let’s start: what’s gonna make a difference? What do we need to invest in to help the organization achieve that goal? I think that’s a little extra step that I would add into that one around identifying those goals.

Jenni: Nice. Right, because I’ve got five, I’m gonna carry on. The next one is the Canva job losses. So, for anyone that missed this, Canva are making some changes that will impact around 22% of the workforce. Now, there’s been lots of positive noise about this announcement and the treatment of those employees that are affected, with some saying this is how you do it right. Now, there are others saying, stop making this sound like it’s a great news story, laying people off should never be normalised, which again we’ve talked about before. So, I want to ask you two things on this because it feels somewhat like organisations can’t win whatever they do. In the Canva example, the offer for impacted employees is genuinely like something I haven’t seen before. Everyone’s getting at least six months of salary. They’re removing the one year vesting cliff for those who joined in the last year. They’ve got 12 months of continued healthcare coverage. They’ve got dedicated career support, they’ve got the ability to keep their MacBook because not everyone has a laptop. And if people are launching their own business, they’ve got a fund where they’re going to do some grants for people that want to go off and do their own thing. So I know that layoffs are not the first answer, but my question, Chuck, is: is it realistic to say that they should never be? Because I think there will be times where you do end up here for whatever reason, but if you do, surely there is a lesson in how to do it with care.

Chuck: Did you see how they ended up here? Why they’re doing the layoffs?

Jenni: So I did have a look and I did see there’s some of the financial challenges that were earlier on in the year, which they did communicate. But I feel like you have done a bit more research there.

Chuck: Right, because I’m in the camp of why are we celebrating this? That’s the camp that I am in. These layoffs happened primarily, it seems like for two reasons. One, this AI spend thing that we’ve talked about before, which is a choice to do. So you’re choosing to spend on that instead of people. And the other thing was their growth. I am a Canva customer. I’ve been a Canva customer for a very long time. I’m gonna guess since 2015, maybe even before. Jenni, their growth isn’t the 30% that they thought they were gonna hit. It’s only 20% growth. So their estimations on growth, which were just simply wrong, are now costing people their jobs. And is the layoff package very generous compared to what other companies have done? Absolutely. But I think that’s this now weird, jaded view that we have that we’re so used to companies treating people like garbage with just minimal effort whatsoever, even just a little bit gets praise. It’s like when you have that friend who’s dating the really bad boyfriend or girlfriend, and they’re just awful for them. But then the next one comes along and is just not quite as awful. So it’s like, my gosh, what an amazing thing. That’s what we’re dealing with here. Six months salary, that is generous compared to what we’re seeing other companies doing. It is not as generous as people keeping their job. Same thing with benefits. Same thing as all these other things that are happening. So did Canva do it better than other people? Sure. It seems like they have. Are they running their business the right way? Certainly doesn’t sound like it if they’re having to lay off this many people at the end of the year, which we talked about. I remember we talked about this last year at the end of the year, how awful it is to lay people off at any time, but especially painful now. Yeah, six months salary and all that stuff, that’s great. That gives people a bit of a cushion. But I’m sure people would much rather just have their job.

Jenni: I completely agree. And I know we spoke about the Gund Company a couple of weeks ago as the example of a company that’s never laid anyone off and how they’ve done it. And I think in situations where it’s, you know, poor financial management or whatever it is, I’m totally in the camp with you that a layoff should be the last resort, if a resort is needed at all. But if it does happen, I do think that there is an element of this should become the standard. Do you know what I mean? Like if you end up there, for whatever reason you might end up there, which you shouldn’t, but if you do, then doing it this way does feel like the right way, in quote marks, to do it. A better… I knew you were gonna go, it’s a better way. It’s a better way, it’s a better way. Yes, a better way.

Chuck: Better way. Like, again, what if we could design what would be the best package? Right? What is the best? Is it a year salary? That would certainly be great, knowing it takes people sometimes a year or more to find a job. But it goes back to the why. If your business is losing money, if your business is shrinking, that to me is, we literally cannot afford to keep these people around. We’re not gonna make payroll if we have the same group of people. That to me makes sense. Not, you’re just not growing at the rate that you thought you were going to grow. So then you’re gonna cut all of these people out of the organization. That’s the part to me that just it just doesn’t add up. It’s not the embarrassment that it used to be when layoffs were almost like, my gosh, what is happening to that business? Now it’s like, well, we’re growing, we’re just only at 20% growth, not 30 that we thought we were gonna be at. So we’re gonna let a lot of people go as a result of us growing. So thank you for helping us grow. So we’re gonna let you go. Maybe I’ll turn that into like a chant. Thanks for letting us grow, so we’re gonna let you go. Thanks for letting us grow, so we’re gonna let you go. There’s just something that just doesn’t feel responsible about this. Canva clearly respected what…

Jenni: You’ve got a thing there. I feel like you’re literally writing it down.

Chuck: …this decision was going to be. Maybe that’s the part that we should applaud is recognizing that. And apparently the communication of it felt very responsible. Like they weren’t diminishing the impact. It’s still an impact. There’s still something wrong in your business that this has happened.

Jenni: Agree, agree. Now my final one, because I have been greedy and done five this week, is about organisations improving leadership communication. Now, this one came across my timeline thanks to Katie Macaulay, who is host of The Internal Comms Podcast and a friend of mine. So thank you to Katie. Now, the headline to take away from the article from Gallup is that this is a belief problem, so not just a communication problem. The post talks about leaders measure what they sent and employees measure what they understood and believed. And I think if you take anything away from our conversation this week, it’s probably that. So leaders know it’s not working. Only 27% of leaders strongly agree that their own leadership communication is effective, yet 58% rate themselves personally as exceptional. So the attitude is the problem is the rest of the team, not me. So I feel like that’s leaders in a lot of places. But interestingly, the gap grows at every level. Leaders rate leaders more highly than managers do, and managers rate managers more highly than their teams do. So this is interesting because I think managers can get a lot of the blame. Gallup are always talking about train managers, that’s the answer. But the data here is saying that the issue starts at the top. So leaders who aren’t aligned but who rate themselves too highly, managers then passing on a message that was already unclear. So there’s something in this for me about not training managers, and I’ve been someone who’s been talking about training managers for a long time, but certainly since I’ve done more work with leadership teams and spent more time with leadership teams certainly in the last two years, we have to start at the top. So my question, Chuck, is how should internal comms teams use this with leaders? Is the self-assessment gap a door opener for the conversation, or is it just going to make leaders just get really defensive and not want to engage with comms?

Chuck: I think it’s all of it. I don’t think this is a door opener. I think you open the door with this. I’m making some comparisons here. I think it’s called the above average effect, where it’s like we think we’re a better driver than everyone else. So this feels a little bit of that, where I’m exceptional. It’s actually the problem of everybody else.

Jenni: It’s Dunning-Kruger, I think. I think it’s the Dunning-Kruger effect.

Chuck: I think that’s the candid or difficult or challenging conversation to have with leaders is to have some sort of assessment in place of not who’s great and who’s not, but how can everybody get better at communication? I think that’s it. Also, to go back to your very… I think Katie is also a friend of mine as well. I don’t think she’s just a friend of yours. I think I would also call Katie a friend of mine.

Jenni: Okay, fair, sorry, I’m sorry about that. I said that because she lives not far away from me, she’s nearby. It was the localized friend. I’m sorry.

Chuck: That’s great. I don’t, Jenni, I don’t let geography define my friendships. So, but I think this is an opportunity for comms leaders. We know how critical leadership communication is. We know the impact it has when it does well. We know the impact it has when it doesn’t. So, how can we level up every single leader knowing they’re all not going to be the greatest communicator of all communicators? But there’s always some simple things that they can do to simply be a bit more clear or build some trust with things, or wherever those gaps are, this is a huge opportunity to recognize not everyone can be, not 58% can be exceptional, and 27% say that leadership communicates effectively. That’s a great starting point to be like, okay, what’s happening inside our organization? What are the gaps that we have? Not personal, not you’re the problem over there, but as an organization, how do we begin to fix and repair some of these things?

Jenni: It got me thinking actually, as you were just chatting then, about a conversation I had with a client this week. They were talking to me about how do I show the impact of my CEO comms? Is there like a standard template report about how you demonstrate that? So we had a really good conversation about it and we ended up coming up with some stuff, but I do think there is something about being able to measure and show the impact and effectiveness of your leadership communication for your organization that helps you have the conversation about the impact rather than the individual behaviour, which I think just helps frame it a little bit better.

Chuck: Pointing back to where it talks about where that gap grows at every level where leaders think they’re better than managers think the leaders are, and managers think they’re better than the teams that report to them think they are. It’s that realization of not necessarily what are people doing wrong, because we know when you get feedback on things like that, people immediately get defensive, the psychology of it. But what can I do to be better? I’m not aware of a lot of people that don’t want to get better or don’t want to improve. We may not like being told what we’re doing wrong. So maybe we need to become a narrative architect around this, Jenni. Maybe we need to think about the chief conversation officer and how we bring those mentalities into architecting the narrative and officiating the conversations to have leaders understand this better.

Jenni: Nice. That was really nice bringing it back to the start. Ten points for that. That was good. Well, that brings us to the end of our articles today. Before I hand over to you for your freq-out, I am gonna go first this week because I saw a post on LinkedIn and it was a post, one of those posts where it’s like a big graphic and a big image. So this post has had nearly 4,000 likes, it’s had over 300 reposts, and it’s got 198 comments or something, and it’s just a big graphic and it says, repeated line after line, “Comms is not a support function. Comms is strategy.” And it’s got all these comments saying, you know, “We need to stop hearing it, we need to start being it,” “Can you print this on a t-shirt?”, “Please say it louder,” “Say it again,” all this stuff. And I sent it to you going, why do we hate being a support function? So there’s something for me here. Maybe I’m showing my age, but when I worked in organisations, which I did for 15, 20 years, the support functions were HR, finance, strategy, comms, marketing, they were the support functions because then you had like the sales team or the operations team and they were supporting those things that were generating the revenue of the organization. That was how it was split. So that’s how in my mind when people talk about a support function, that’s what I think about. I think about all these functions that are supporting the revenue generating side of the organization essentially, the people that are serving the customers or those people that are sort of on the front line of that sales and stuff. And I just wonder why we have such an allergic reaction to it when to me it encompasses so many other functions, and it freq-ed me out a little bit. Like, why do we have such a violent allergic reaction to it? Do you have a violent allergic reaction to that?

Chuck: It just goes into that pile of other LinkedIn content that I just simply do not like. Here’s what I will find. I don’t have any science behind this or any backing to it, but it seems like the more support or this like gang up mentality that piling on mentality that happens with content when I see that, the less I like it. Because again, I want to have people think about this very critically. Are we then saying that strategy is not support? If like those things have to be separate buckets, and to your point, somebody has to be a support function. Who’s not supporting the business? Are we saying finance is a support function? Like that’s supporting the business. It’s also strategy. Like there’s strategy behind what they’re doing. So it’s not a this or that. You’re both. Now I think where this is touching a nerve is a little bit on the other thing, and I’ll probably bring some pitchforks out for this, where people talk about like don’t be an order taker, be an oracle. Well, we all take orders. We all take orders. Like, come on. I get the idea. I get what we’re aiming for. We all take orders. So you can and should be strategic. You should also be supporting the business. So I just don’t get the response. I don’t get this vitriol. I don’t get the piling on the pitchforks coming out. Like it’s a LinkedIn image. And I almost don’t want to read it. I saw the image. I don’t even want to go into the comments because I just feel like I’m gonna be disappointed by the people in there. So that’s my take.

Jenni: Fair, fair, fair. Well that’s good. So I’ll be interested if any of our listeners feel the same, whether they have an allergic reaction to support function.

Chuck: Clearly they do. Well, I know some people that listen to us have probably responded to this graphic. And I just want to challenge people, please think critically about this stuff. And if you’ve really thought it through and you still believe it, like it, love it, applaud it, celebrate it, whatever on there, but just really think about what we’re saying here.

Jenni: Yeah, that’s my point. That’s exactly it. Right, over to you. What’s your freq-out this week?

Chuck: Yes, my freq-out. Much more positive, because I want to be the optimist here on the podcast. I mentioned that timing, the timing gods are on my side, the music gods are on my side, being able to see my favorite band, Duran Duran, in Madrid while I was there. It turned out to be the final stop on the European tour. And this will mean nothing to you, Jenni, but it was just announced today that Roger Taylor, who’s been the longtime drummer for Duran Duran, he’s done. He’s out. I don’t want to say retiring, I don’t know, but apparently because of tinnitus, he just doesn’t want to do it anymore. So I saw his final show, which means a lot to me as a fan. I hate to see Roger go, but good for him. What a run they’ve been on. However, I even said this to you that I just felt like I was gonna make friends at the show.

Jenni: You did, in our last episode. You were like, I’m gonna make some friends, I guarantee it.

Chuck: This was my first ever time going to a concert solo, which again, very vulnerable, foreign country. First ever time in the city going to a show. Do not speak the language. Obviously, I speak the language of Duran Duran, but not Spanish. Made my way into the show, kind of standing there in the front row area. I wasn’t, I wasn’t like at the stage, but I was in that front pocket of people standing up. A couple minutes before the show starts, I get this tap on the shoulder, turn around. It’s a friend from college, Jenni. I met this person 30 years ago at Butler University, friend from college. She was there with her husband, who is a Duran Duran fan. They also were in Madrid because they’re Atlanta Falcons fans, who were playing my beloved Bengals. So they were there, but then she told me the reason she saw me, because I was in front of them, was she’s like telling her husband, is this a good spot to be in? He’s like, “Yes, except for this tall guy in the white shirt standing in front of me.” Then apparently at some point I turned to where she recognized me. That’s when she came up. So great to reconnect, great to meet her husband. Also for him and I to chat a bit about Duran Duran and the quality of the show, and of course how much we love them. But then I offered to them, I was like, hey, I’m meeting my wife and her friend out somewhere in Madrid for drinks after the show. Do you want to join us? And they’re like, absolutely. So then they joined me. We tracked down my wife, Kristen, and her friend Nicole. So, Jen and Will, great to see you in Madrid. They’re probably not listening, but I’ll shout them out here: in Madrid at the Duran Duran show, joining us out for drinks. It was that reminder, Jenni. We have these interactions all the time. But just a reminder of truly how small this world we are in is. And also, I mean, if I’d have been 10 feet one direction, we might not have connected. Also, thirdly, Jenni, maybe a great time to end the show on or great theme to end the show on. Just don’t be a dick to people. Right? If I’d have been a jerk in school, do you think she would have, she’d have been like, my god, I know him, but we’re not talking, you know, right? So just have fun, be good to people. Be good to people. You never know 30 years later you’re gonna be at a Duran Duran show in Madrid and reconnect with someone.

Jenni: Yeah, love that. Love that. Well, thank you for joining us this week. We hope that the articles and insights will help you think about how to improve comms, leadership and culture in your organisation. If you don’t yet subscribe or follow, please do, as it helps make sure you won’t miss an episode. And you can grab links to all of the stories we’ve talked about on our website, thefrequencypodcast.com, where you can find details about every episode we have done. We’ll be back with you on Monday with more news, insights, and opinions about everything comms and leadership in workplaces today. Thank you for spending part of your week with us.

About the hosts

Picture of Chuck Gose

Chuck Gose

Chuck is a US-based internal communications strategist and the founder of ICology – a community and resource hub for IC professionals. He brings a practitioner lens to every conversation. Chuck is a recognised voice in the industry, a regular speaker and event host, and one of the most connected people in the North American IC world.

Learn More
Picture of Jenni Field

Jenni Field

Jenni is a UK-based leadership and internal communications consultant, author of two best-selling books, and international speaker. She runs Redefining Communications, a consultancy working with organisations around the world to help them communicate better and close the gap between what leaders say and what employees experience.

Learn More

Get the latest conversation delivered to your inbox.

Great! We’ve received your information.

Every week get the episode delivered straight to your inbox with the show notes and article links.

Search